Guides ›
Short answer: both are good brands, but for Oklahoma hail, wind and heat swings, Eric recommends Malarkey rubberized asphalt shingles. The Vista AR line is Class 4 impact rated, the rubber keeps the shingle flexible in heat and cold, and a Class 4 roof may qualify you for an insurance premium discount. The exact product line matters more than the logo.
Watch: Eric on why he uses Malarkey
Eric on why he uses Malarkey (53 sec). Watch on YouTube
Last updated:
Start by asking which Malarkey shingle and which GAF shingle are actually under consideration. Write both names on the estimate. Then compare the attributes that matter to your house: impact rating, appearance, installed roof details and the warranty being offered. A conversation that stays at brand level can miss the biggest differences within each manufacturer's own range.
The table below is a starting point, not a substitute for the current product documents. If you are comparing Vista AR with a GAF product, ask the roofer to identify the exact GAF line rather than writing Timberline alone. Product names and specifications deserve the same care as the total price. You should know what is being delivered before the materials arrive at the property.
No. Rubberized asphalt describes the material approach; Class 4 is an impact rating for a particular product. Confirm both the material and the rating of the exact line being quoted.
Confirm the approved product and color before ordering, then ask for the estimate to identify that selection. Discuss any required change with the roofer before approving materials.
No. An impact rating is not a promise that a storm cannot damage the roof. Have new leaks or suspected storm damage assessed rather than assuming the rating rules out a problem.
Rubberized asphalt describes the material approach Eric prefers. An impact class describes a product's stated rating. Those are related parts of the buying discussion, but they are not interchangeable labels. Do not assume every product under one brand has the same class. The existing comparison on this page identifies Highlander AR as Class 3 and Vista AR as Class 4.
Likewise, a GAF name does not automatically mean the shingle lacks an impact-rated option. This guide identifies Timberline AS II as an impact-rated line and distinguishes it from standard Timberline HDZ. Ask for the current product documentation for the line on your proposal. That gives you a specific item to discuss with both the installer and your insurance agent, instead of relying on a broad brand reputation.
Class 4 can be an important reason to choose a shingle in Oklahoma. It should not be read as a promise that no hailstorm can damage the finished roof. A roof has more parts than the exposed shingle surface. Ask how the proposal addresses the whole assembly and what to do if a later storm causes a leak or visible damage.
Separate impact resistance from wind and algae questions too. A product can have more than one performance feature, and a short sales phrase does not explain all of them. Ask the roofer to show you where each relevant claim appears in the manufacturer's information. You do not need to memorize a specification sheet. You do need to know which claims describe your selected product.
If an HOA controls roof appearance, resolve the permitted product and color before ordering. If you are matching an addition to an existing GAF roof, take that requirement into the comparison early. Choosing only by impact rating can leave a separate appearance question unanswered. Eric's recommendation can be part of the decision without ignoring a real constraint at your property.
Ask to review the proposed color and product together. A color name alone does not tell you the impact class or the roof system being quoted. Keep any HOA response with the estimate. If a required product changes, ask for a revised proposal so the material name, cost and warranty discussion all refer to the same selection. Do not rely on an earlier conversation about a different shingle.
The roof's underlayment, flashing and ventilation are not decided by the brand logo alone. Have the installer explain those parts of the plan. Ask what is included around existing roof penetrations and how the condition below the old shingles will be checked. A premium product name is not an answer to a question about work elsewhere on the roof.
When bids use different products, first identify whether the installation scopes also differ. Otherwise you may credit a price difference entirely to the shingles when it reflects different work. Keep the comparison in two columns: the named product and the planned installation. That simple separation makes it easier to ask useful follow-up questions and avoids turning a whole-roof decision into a contest between labels.
Ask which warranty applies to the proposed job and what is required for it. Manufacturer coverage and workmanship coverage address different subjects. A long number in a sales conversation is not the complete agreement. Ask about eligibility, registration, transfer rules and exclusions in the documents for the actual roof, rather than assuming a warranty applies to every property.
This matters if you are comparing a primary residence with another type of property. Do not carry a warranty statement from one job into another without checking it. If two proposals mention different coverage, ask each contractor to explain the difference in writing. Keep the documents with your estimate so the decision is based on the coverage being offered, not just the most memorable number.
If a premium reduction is part of your reason for upgrading, ask your carrier about the exact line you are considering. Saying Malarkey, GAF or architectural shingle may not answer the carrier's question. Ask what proof it needs after installation. The final decision about a premium reduction belongs to the insurer, not to the shingle salesperson or the roofing contractor.
Eric supplies the Insurance Premium Reduction Request Form with the final invoice for a Malarkey Class 4 roof. Keep that step separate from choosing a material you want on the house. A possible discount can support the decision, but it is not guaranteed money. Choose with a clear view of the quoted product, the installed scope and the written coverage first.
| Malarkey (AR line) | GAF | |
|---|---|---|
| Shingle type | Rubberized (polymer-modified) asphalt across the AR line | Mostly standard asphalt; polymer-modified on select impact lines |
| Impact rating | Vista AR: Class 4 · Highlander AR: Class 3 | Timberline AS II: Class 4 · Timberline HDZ: not sold as Class 4 |
| Algae resistance | Built into the AR line | Available on many lines |
| Recycled content | Uses recycled rubber and plastics in the shingle | Varies by product |
| Made / distributed | Distributed in Oklahoma | Nationwide, the largest U.S. shingle maker |
| Who installs it here | Scott 1 Roofing, Malarkey Certified Pro #5702 | Many Tulsa-area contractors |
Ratings and product details come from each manufacturer and can change. Confirm the exact product line on your written estimate.
"GAF" or "Malarkey" on a quote doesn't tell you much. Each company sells several product lines with different impact ratings, warranties and prices. Two GAF roofs can perform very differently, and so can two Malarkey roofs. Ask your estimate to name the manufacturer and the product line.
Oklahoma gets large hail, straight-line wind and summer-to-winter temperature swings. Standard asphalt gets brittle as it ages and bakes, so it cracks and loses granules when hail hits. Rubber-modified asphalt stays flexible, so it is better at taking a hit without cracking.
If your HOA requires a specific GAF color, or you are matching an addition to an existing GAF roof, a GAF product may be the right call. Just make sure an impact-rated line is quoted if hail protection or an insurance discount matters to you.
Many insurers offer a discount on Class 4 impact-rated roofs. Eric gives you the Insurance Premium Reduction Request Form with your final invoice, and your insurer decides the amount. More in our Malarkey Class 4 & insurance premium guide.
Both are quality manufacturers. For Oklahoma hail, wind and heat, Eric Scott recommends Malarkey rubberized asphalt shingles because the rubber-modified asphalt stays flexible and Malarkey's Vista AR line is Class 4 impact rated. GAF makes good shingles too; what matters most is the exact product line and the crew installing it.
Yes. GAF sells impact-rated lines such as Timberline AS II, and its standard Timberline HDZ is not sold as a Class 4 product. Always ask your estimate to name the exact product line, not just the brand.
AR stands for Advanced Resistance: impact resistant, wind resistant and algae resistant. Malarkey Highlander AR is Class 3 and Vista AR is Class 4.
It may. Many Oklahoma insurers offer a discount for Class 4 impact-rated roofs. Eric gives you an Insurance Premium Reduction Request Form with your final invoice; your insurer decides the discount.
Not necessarily. As a Malarkey Certified Pro, Scott 1 Roofing can price a Class 4 rubberized asphalt shingle about where many companies price a Class 3 shingle. Every roof is quoted after a free inspection.
Scott 1 Roofing specializes in Malarkey and also installs other shingle, metal and tile roofs. Ask Eric during your free inspection and he will walk you through the options side by side.
More short videos from Eric
Related: Rubberized asphalt vs. standard asphalt · Rubberized asphalt shingles · Class 4 impact-resistant roofing · Roof replacement · Roof replacement cost guide
Malarkey roof installs in Sapulpa · Bixby · Tulsa · Broken Arrow · Jenks · Glenpool · Owasso · Sand Springs and across Oklahoma.
Call, text or send the form. You will hear back from Scott 1 Roofing, not a call center.
(539) 432-1383Hours: Open 24 hours Monday–Saturday; closed Sunday. For a roofing emergency, call to confirm availability.